Don’t get me wrong, I love Joe Girardi as a manager and I
think he does a great job of getting players ready for the games and does a
great job with the many day-to-day responsibilities that an MLB manager faces.
He brought the Yankees their 27th world championship in only his
second year managing the team and in my book that cements his place in the
history of the storied Yankees franchise. However, when it comes to managing in
game situations, especially late in games, frankly he sucks. I almost
feel like I could do a better job managing the team in late game situations. It
seems like he’s thinking too much and trying to make everything perfect and
have everything play out like a script. But the fact is that baseball games are
ever changing and the great in game managers have great instincts, they just
know what to do and what calls to make. Joe Girardi lacks this ability.
There are plenty of good examples of this and one perfect example was earlier this year in the first inning of the year against the rays. There were runners on second and third with two outs and CC Sabbathia, the Yankees ace, was on the hill. Sean Rodriguez was at the plate and the dangerous Carlos Pena was on deck. Joe Girardi thought it was a good idea to intentionally walk Rodriguez in this situation. I understand what Girardi was thinking, but I couldn't agree less with this decision at this point in the game. He was thinking that it was a good idea to walk the righty Rodriguez against the lefty Sabbathia to get to the lefty-lefty match-up against Pena where the pitcher statistically has the advantage. Sean Rodriguez also has better numbers against Sabbathia than Pena does, but in a sample size that small you can pretty much throw statistics out the window. Anyway, he walk Rodriguez and Pena hit a grand slam to put the Rays up 4-0. The first inning of the year is not the time to worry about match-ups. You let your ace pitch and let him do his job. Maybe he gets out of the inning against Rodriguez, maybe he doesn't, but you gotta give CC the chance their to pitch his way out of it. I am confident that Joe Girardi is the only manager in the MLB that would have made that call, because he over manages games. He needs to take a step back and let his players do their jobs.
What happened afterwards was pretty funny. Girardi got a whole lot of criticism for the move (a lot more than he would have 20-30 years ago). The Yankees blogosphere blew up in reaction to the managing style. It ranged from "he needs to relax" to "we need to fire him immediately" but none of the reactions were good. This is what the internet and the increased sharing inhibits. There is no relief for a manager or a player if they screw up, especially in New York. There is heightened scrutiny for anything a player or manager does and the internet and blogs has a lot to do with that.